HTC U11 review (hands-on): The squeezy smartphone with the best camera in the business

Jonathan Bray May 15, 2017

Image 1 of 21

The HTC U11 may or may not turn out to be the best smartphone of 2017, but it’s certainly the most intriguing so far. Teased early last month with the bizarre tagline “Squeeze for the Brilliant”, HTC’s latest flagship set tongues wagging and overactive imaginations running over time. What could it be? A smartphone-cum-stress toy? Maybe a ruggedised handset with impact-resistant edges?

Well, today we find out, and it’s none of those things. Instead, the squeezable element in the new HTC U11 is “Edge Sense” and it consists of a series of pressure sensors built into the lower half of the frame of the phone. These allow you to launch apps from the lockscreen and carry out various actions within those apps.

HTC calls this new way of interacting with your phone “extended touch”, and predictably it says it’s a revolution. In reality, it’s far from that. Instead, it’s a nice-to-have extra; something that will let you launch the camera app and snap a selfie without having to find a button or locate a button, but not, I’ll wager, something rival manufacturers will be chomping at the bit to build into their next handset.

[gallery:4]

HTC U11 review: How does Edge Sense work?

Basically, there are two types of squeeze you can apply to the HTC U11: a short and a long squeeze. Like I said, Edge Sense is a pretty simple concept.

Squeezes are accompanied by a short dig of haptic feedback – so you know when to grasp the edges a little harder – and each type of squeeze can be assigned to launch any app you like. This works from the lockscreen with the phone in standby or from the homescreen.

Once you’re in an app, squeezes become context-sensitive (which sounds ridiculous; please bear with me), so in the camera app a short squeeze fires off a frame and a long squeeze switches between selfie and rear camera modes. Initially, these in-app actions will be restricted to HTC apps such as the camera app, but in July the firm will be releasing an Edge Sense add-on via Google Play that will allow users to add customisable actions to any third-party app.

[gallery:6]

And what if you’re weak and feeble like Olive Oyl or you’re a bit of a Popeye and don’t know your own spinach-driven strength? No need to worry: the sensitivity can be adjusted through the phone’s settings. This way you can be sure it isn’t too much of an effort to trigger Edge Sense actions and that you don’t trigger them by accident.

That’s Edge Sense in a nutshell, but the HTC U11 isn’t only about squeezy gimmickry. In fact, there’s plenty else to get stuck into here.

HTC U11 review: Features, design and first impressions

From a design perspective, the HTC U11 looks similar to the HTC U Play and HTC U Ultra phones launched at CES at the beginning of the year. That means it sports the same smooth, pebble-like “liquid” surface look and rounded 3D-glass edge profiles.

There are a couple of new colours, though: a blue-ish “Amazing Silver” and the rather fetching two-tone “Solar Red” (arriving later in the year), which shifts colour between burnished gold and a lustrous red as you tilt the phone in your hand.

Other than that, the new phone looks very similar to its stablemates, which isn’t to say it’s dull. In fact, the solar red model looks incredible. The way this phone catches and reflects the light is incredible to see; there’s no other phone like it. But it is disappointing that there’s no ultra-widescreen, bezel-free display like the Samsung Galaxy S8 and LG G6 to go with that amazing finish.

[gallery:17]

Instead, the HTC U11 has a 5.5in IPS-based Super LCD 5 screen with a resolution of 1,440 x 2,560 (qHD), and bog-standard bezels above and below it.

The HTC U11 is dust- and water-resistant and rated to IP67; that’s a notch below the S8, but since you can dunk the phone in up to a metre of water for 30 minutes, as opposed to 1.5m for the S8, there’s not too much of a practical difference here. It should survive being drowned in the sink briefly just as well as a Samsung Galaxy S8.

There’s also a fingerprint reader on the front, below the screen in the centre, and a microSD slot allowing the addition of up to 2TB of extra space should the built-in 64GB or 128GB not be enough for you.

[gallery:3]

HTC U11 review: Performance and battery life

The HTC U11 will be only the second phone we’ve seen this year to run the Qualcomm Snapdragon 835 chip after the Sony Xperia XZ Premium – the S8 makes a third, but the 835 model is only available in the US – and it comes with either 4GB of RAM and 64GB of storage, or 6GB of RAM and 128GB of storage.

It ought to be incredibly quick and responsive, then, and it certainly felt that way when I had the chance to handle the phone briefly prior to the launch announcement, but that’s not the only aspect of performance that has been improved for the HTC U11. One more thing the new processor should beef up is battery life. In fact, HTC is claiming the HTC U11 offers up to 45% better battery life than the HTC 10, and that’s despite the fact that the phone has the same size battery as its predecessor at 3,000mAh.

[gallery:13]

It also supports Quick Charge 3, which will give you “one day of use” through 30 minutes of charging. It’s slightly odd that it doesn’t support QuickCharge 4, which is the latest standard and built into the Snapdragon 835 chipset.

HTC U11 review: Cameras

As for the cameras, HTC is focusing on speed and performance rather than outright quality this year. According to HTC, this is a camera that goes “beyond image quality” to build a “fluid camera experience”. In the real world, this translates as improved autofocus performance via a dual-pixel autofocus sensor and faster HDR shots, courtesy of the ISP in the Snapdragon 835 chip.

Otherwise, the specifications look perfectly decent. The rear camera is a 12-megapixel unit with an f/1.7 aperture and optical image stabilisation, just like the Galaxy S8. The front-facing camera captures images at a huge 16 megapixels, has a 150-degree field of view and an f/2.0 lens.

In fact, the camera is better than decent. The imaging experts at Paris-based DxOMark have already tested the camera in depth and awarded it a score of 90; that’s one better than the illustrious Google Pixel, which has held the crown, despite stiff competition, since its launch at the end of 2016. It scored 90 out of 100 in the photo tests and 89 in the video tests, which is the highest score ever awarded for video in a smartphone camera in the DxOMark tests. In particular, DxOMark notes that the image stabilisation “is very effective” and has a flash that provides even exposure in a variety of different situations.

I’ll run my own tests on the camera, of course when I get hold of one (hopefully soon), but this bodes well for the success of HTC’s latest handset.

HTC U11 review: Audio and headphones

HTC is revisiting its trademark BoomSound speaker technology for the launch of the HTC U11. Disappointingly, this doesn’t mean the return of the twin, front-facing speakers that graced the HTC One M8 and One M9 – audio emanates from the earpiece speaker and the grille on the bottom edge as with last year’s HTC 10 – but it’s the most powerful BoomSound speaker setup yet, according to HTC.

Perhaps more interesting is the inclusion of improved in-box earphones. Just as with the HTC 10, these “Usonic” earphones are able to scan your ear canal and automatically tailor the audio profile appropriately so the sound isn’t overly bassy or tinny. This year, however, HTC is adding active noise cancellation. That’s a pretty sweet deal, since decent active noise-cancelling headphones can cost £100 or more.

[gallery:18]

HTC is also sticking to its guns on removing the 3.5mm headphone jack, but it is including an adapter in the box with active amplification.

Finally, HTC has also added a quad-microphone array to the HTC U11, capable of recording “3D” audio. Notably, these microphones can be set to be always listening, so when the phone’s upcoming Alexa capability becomes available in July, you’ll be able to use it on the go just like you do your housebound Echo or Echo Dot.

HTC U11 review: Price and early verdict

There’s plenty going on with HTC’s new flagship phone and, although a little late to the party this year, it looks like it could be pretty competitive.

The big sticking point, without the ultra-widescreen bezel-free design of rivals, will most likely be its price, which HTC has set at a rather hopeful £649 inc VAT.

That, ladies and gentlemen, is the same as the LG G6 and only £30 less expensive than the Samsung Galaxy S8. And while I can’t say for definite whether it’s worth it or not yet, it’s clear that it will need to be absolutely brilliant at that price.