Daydream View review: Google’s 2017 version is a modest improvement
Alongside our Pixel 2 and Pixel 2 XL units, Google sent us the ever-so-slightly different Daydream View units. In truth, the headsets are barely changed, and don’t warrant a full review of their own – especially as you can no longer buy the first generation.
That’s not to say they’re bad – there’s a certain element of “if it ain’t broke” at play here. The fabric is now feels a bit more rugged than soft – presumably to ensure it’s a bit more durable over time, which feels like a smart move.
^The new 2017 Google Daydream in all its glory.
The lenses have been switched out too, and the Daydream View now packs dual Fresnel lenses. This has both up and downsides – the viewing angles are slightly wider, meaning you’ll be turning less, but the downside is that they’re a bit less crisp than the old versions. Not a problem for general gawking around in VR, but noticable when trying to read text. Overall, it’s probably a sacrifice worth making.
Otherwise, it’s mainly the same as ever. I own a Gear VR as well, and prefer the quick, no-fuss setup of Google’s offering, though the store feels a bit less well curated. Still, the fact that Google has come back with a second version suggests they’re in this VR game for the long haul. And that can only be a good thing.
Tom’s original review continues below. Pretty much everything said below still applies.
Google Daydream View review
Daydream is the perfect name for Google’s fabric-coated VR headset. It’s actually a good word to capture the entirety of virtual reality, or at least the version peddling itself as an accessible entry point, where phones are slipped into plastic cases and strapped to heads. If cinemas are dark, lucid spaces for dreaming, then Google’s Daydream View is a place for forays into reverie. Where you forget, if only for a moment, when and where and who you are.
With a reasonable £69 price tag and an easy-to-use setup that taps into Google’s Material Design philosophy, the Daydream View stands to redefine smartphone-based VR. Throw in the fact that Google’s experience seamlessly integrates with YouTube and its bank of 360-degree video, and this headset is one of the best reasons to get behind virtual reality as an everyday medium.
Google Daydream View review: Design
Google’s main competitor here is the Samsung Gear VR. Like that headset, the Daydream View is essentially a pair of fancy goggles for housing a high-resolution smartphone. There’s nothing in the way of wires or sensors, and Google leans into this simplicity with a design aesthetic that’s more about squishy cloth than shiny plastic.
The casing of the headset comes in one of three colours – Slate, Snow or Crimson – although only the first will be available at launch. The soft fabric shell and curved shape give the Daydream View a cosy appearance, although the casing does look a bit like someone has taken a pair of scissors to a Topman T-shirt. It remains an unpretentiously handsome device, however, and much like the Google Cardboard, this use of textile lends the headset a pleasing tactility.[gallery:6]
Attached to your face, the Daydream View feels comfortable and lightweight. A squishy microfibre face mask lines the area that’s pressed against your forehead, and there’s a cavity for the viewer’s nose. The bottom lining could, however, have been designed to push tighter against the nose and cheeks. I found there to be an irritating gap where light and dust could get in. This wasn’t noticeable when playing in low-light spaces, but it occasionally broke the sense of immersion when using the Daydream View during the day.
The headset’s strap is angled to clasp around the top part of its user’s head, and it can be easily tightened or loosened using buckles on either side. There isn’t a top strap to stop the Daydream View from slumping down over time, but the headset with smartphone ensconced is light enough for this not to be an issue. The lack of top strap also means you can use the Daydream View with, say, a topknot or Mohawk – if that happens to be a clincher for you.
Unlike the Gear VR, the Daydream View has no focus-adjustment dial. Configuring your view is more a task of fiddling the headset’s position on your forehead until the image becomes clear. This worked fine for me, although it may be worth trying out the Daydream View before buying it, if only to check that the focus works for your vision.
Google Daydream View review: Smartphones
I tried the Daydream View with Google’s 5.5in Pixel XL handset, but the VR device also works with the standard Pixel, and will eventually be compatible with a host of Android phones. As of 1 August 2017, the Daydream VR is additionally available on the Samsung Galaxy S8 and Samsung Galaxy S8 Plus. The rollout schedule has not been revealed, but a tweet from Google VR simply said support was coming.
The ZTE Axon 7 and Huawei Mate 9 were among the first non-Google smartphones to work with Daydream, and this increased breadth of compatibility gives the Daydream View a major leg up over the Gear VR, which is limited to Samsung’s own devices.
Whereas Samsung’s Gear VR has panels that slot and click into place, the Daydream View’s phone-holder sandwiches the handset between capacitive rubberised nubs, fastened with an elastic latch. This was enough to keep my Google Pixel XL secure during my time with the headset, although I’d worry that repeated wear and tear would weaken the elastic hook.[gallery:3]
The nubs let the phone know where it’s positioned in the headset, removing the need to precisely sandwich your phone as was the case with Google’s Cardboard. The bottom hinge on the panel also slides out on spring-loaded arms, accommodating phones of different sizes or those with cases. An embedded NFC chip automatically switches the phone to Daydream mode when placed on the headset’s panel, and while I had one or two instances of the phone not properly segueing into Daydream mode, the setup process is so quick that it wasn’t an issue to take out the handset and manually enter the app.
When using Daydream, the screen is smooth and reactive, with low latency and nothing too overpowering in the way of motion blur. I shook my head pretty violently to try and make the phone stutter, but didn’t feel motion-sick in the slightest when using it. As with the Gear VR, however, I did find that my eyes grew tired after using the headset for prolonged periods of time.
Google Daydream View review: Remote control
While Google has bucked against the Gear VR in a very obvious way with its design decisions, the real game-changer in the Daydream View is its inclusion of a separate, movement-sensing controller.
This small, pill-shaped device continues Google’s stripped-back approach to VR, having only a clickable touchpad and two menu buttons, plus volume controls on its side.
It connects with your smartphone via Bluetooth, and has internal sensors so it can tell where it’s pointed. There’s no external spatial à la the Oculus Rift, HTC Vive and PlayStation VR, but the Daydream View controller can pick up directional shifts in movement. The result is a system that’s more about wrist movements than expansive sweeps of the arm, with the controller used to point at menus and objects as opposed to reaching out and interacting with items in the virtual space.[gallery:7]
Compared with the Gear VR’s headset-based control buttons – which mean you have to press the side of your head to interact with things – the Daydream View’s controller is far more comfortable to use. The experience is much like using a computer mouse, but for virtual reality, and the directional sensors work well in conjunction with the trackpad. I did find myself having to re-centre the camera to keep my gaze lined up with the pointer, but this is done by simply holding down one of the buttons. Annoyingly, the fact that this is the same button used to exit apps meant I accidentally ended up back on the homescreen more than once.
There’s a wrist strap included with the Daydream View, which can be used to prevent the controller from crashing into friends and family if it flies out of your grip. There’s also a handy niche in the headset’s panel — an ideal place to store the controller when you’re not using it.
Google Daydream View review: Content library
Google’s Daydream UI doesn’t diverge drastically from Samsung’s Gear VR. Similarly, it’s built from square panels floating against a pleasant, animated scene. There’s no real need for Google to opt for a different design, as it works well and makes sense at a glance.
What is currently within those panels, however, is somewhat limited. At launch, Google only has a handful of Daydream games ready for download on Google Play. While these showcase the headset’s co-ordination with its controller, they largely lack depth. Wonderglade, for example, is a kid-friendly set of mini-games that involve the player rotating their hand to race a ball around a moveable track. Hunters Gate, meanwhile, is a top-down, Diablo-like RPG, which sees your character movement controlled by trackpad, and your aim controlled by pointing at enemies. Both are diverting, but there’s not much to them, and they don’t make the most of the sense of immersion VR offers.
Much more appealing is the Harry Potter tie-in Fantastic Beasts, in which you charm a number of magical creatures using movements of your controller/wand. There isn’t a great variety of actions you can perform, but the set design is lush and detailed – absorbing to explore. Also worth playing is British developer Mike Bithell’s EarthShape, in which you travel to terraform alien planets via a grid-based mini-game. Again, the action is far from fast-paced, but the gameplay is meditative and the writing has character.
Aside from games, Daydream is slated to host content from The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, the BBC and The Guardian, going to show that newspapers and broadcasters are leading the charge when it comes to interesting uses of VR. Another thing in its favour is its integration with YouTube, making the Daydream View an open gateway into a whole world of user-generated 360-degree films.
More experiences for the Daydream will inevitably arrive in the next few months, but it is important that Google pushes games and films that go further than novelty in engaging with the idea of immersion. There’s a lot of scope for developers and directors to do interesting things with VR, and Daydream’s accessibility could make it a perfect platform for sophisticated projects that aim for a wider audience than early adopters of the Oculus Rift, HTC Vive and PlayStation VR.[gallery:3]
Google Daydream View review: Verdict
With the Cardboard, Google took a knowingly anti-tech approach to VR, and this attitude continues with a headset that feels more like an item of clothing than a holster for expensive hardware. It works. The Daydream View makes pivoting into virtual reality feel smooth and intuitive, and using it is greatly helped by a responsive controller.
Aside from the current dearth of content to use with it, the Daydream is well positioned to seize the ground established by Samsung’s Gear VR. It could do more than this, potentially redefining what we think of when we talk about smartphone-based virtual reality.