There’s an AI for everything these days, and we seem to be all too happy to hand over complex tasks to chatbots and specialized machine learning tools, so we can focus on other things. Essay writing is one such area where the tedium of researching, structuring, writing, and citing can seem like too much trouble. Yet are AI essay writers any good? In this article, we’ll be weighing up the pros and cons.
The Promises and Limitations of AI Essay Writers
Everybody wants an ultimate solution to any problem. But is that really the best? AI essay writing is not yet the complete miracle tool that’ll construct an original and thoroughly researched essay in a heartbeat (with doubts that it ever will be), but it can be helpful as a supplemental tool. Modern essay writers, like Grammarly, Quillbot, and Aithor AI, have gone far beyond simple text generation and offer various benefits, including:
- Outline and essay structure generation
- A choice of styles to match a particular tone, including academic
- Ability to edit and reformulate existing and generated parts of essays
- Proofreading and editing
- Translation of sources and existing work into a native language
But is AI good at writing essays? Let’s explore the pros and cons:
The Pros
Let’s start positively. Here are some great advantages of AI essay writers:
- Structure generation – If you have a topic that you’re not even sure how to begin to break down, an essay writer can help you with a simple text prompt. If you can start writing with a solid structure or plan, you’re well on your way.
- Say it again – If the essay language isn’t your native tongue, AI can help rephrase, enhance, and optimize your words into something better. It might not do so consistently, but it’s a great start.
- Research assistance – Essay writers can be a great assistant when it comes to diving into topics. Don’t know where to start researching, or need some sources for an obscure topic? They can help you search effectively.
- Ideas – Sometimes you don’t know where to go next, or what other areas you can explore. A nudge from an essay writer can bust your writer’s block and give you a new perspective.
The Cons
There’s a lot these writers can do, but there are also areas where they stumble:
- Plagiarism and incorrect sources – Plagiarism is a cardinal sin in academia, and the ease with which an essay writer can scrape existing work without crediting the author can lead to such a charge, whether the user is aware or not.
- Hallucinations and inaccuracies – No matter how advanced the AI, these tools are still subject to hallucinating facts, inaccuracies, and outright fabrications. This extends from sources to research, making double-checking links and citations an absolute necessity.
- Lack of specificity – As LLMs are trained on large data sets, they specialize in broad outlines of topics, but fail when getting into the niche areas. The more specialized your research, the more AI will fall short. What’s more, AI essay writers generate text that is frustratingly vague at times and often generic.
- Overreliance – If using essay writers to do everything for you, not only do you risk being detected by AI detectors, but the robotic nature of your essay will fail to bring the originality you’re looking for. If not used as a supplemental tool, users run the risk of decreasing their critical thinking skills and not fully understanding their work, which can have long-term professional and educational implications.
Disclaimer: Some pages on this site may include an affiliate link. This does not effect our editorial in any way.
